20 Mar '15 22:15>
I am tired of American ideologues repeatedly parroting claims about public sector enterprises and government planning in the economy. I have decided to refer to one useful article - written in 2010 - that sets out some of the achievements of the French public sector.
Like the 2008 total collapse of the banking system throughout the developed world, these public sector success stories are supposed to be impossible according to the neoliberal free market orthodoxy which presently holds us all (especially in the US and the UK) in its thrall.
Even after repeated rounds of privatization, a substantial share of France’s economy remains in state hands. In 2006, the state controlled ninety companies directly (representing 3.7 percent of total employment) and 755 indirectly (notably via the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations, an institution nationalized just after the Second World War, which today functions something like a discrete sovereign fund). Its holdings include not only controlling interests like its 85 percent of Électricité de France, but also minority stakes—35.7 percent of Gaz de France-Suez and 27 percent of France Télécom. At the financial market’s 2007 zenith, its portfolio was estimated at 191.9 billion euros.
And in the aggregate, these companies not only cost taxpayers nothing, but may well keep taxes down. The state’s biggest fully owned enterprises, for example, are flourishing, even in this increasingly difficult climate. La Poste’s annual profits fell to a more than respectable 530 million euros in 2008. The SNCF (the state railway monopoly created in 1938 during the Popular Front) saw its profits drop from 1.1 billion euros in 2007 to 575 million in 2008—all the while employing 158,000 railway workers, charging passengers considerably less than Amtrak or its privatized British counterparts, keeping France’s carbon-gas emissions low, and operating what is one of the best rail systems in the world. Indeed, nationalized businesses are an important source of regular revenue for the state. For fiscal 2008 alone, the shareholder-state received no less than 5.6 billion euros in dividends from its holdings.
But nationalization’s benefits have been much broader than simple profits. Over the entire period since the Liberation, French planning’s record of creating employment and prosperity is considerably better than neoliberal critics would have it. The state has used planning as a flexible tool to restructure companies and save jobs, to create new industries from scratch and promote job growth, to soften deindustrialization’s blow to workers and their communities, and to orient transportation and energy policy onto more sustainable pathways.
Like the 2008 total collapse of the banking system throughout the developed world, these public sector success stories are supposed to be impossible according to the neoliberal free market orthodoxy which presently holds us all (especially in the US and the UK) in its thrall.